The transition to the era of electric vehicles is happening rapidly. India is also making progress in the same direction. Indians, however, continue to adore their traditional CNG cars. This begs the question, “CNG vs. Electric Vehicles”: What is the most economical option for urban driving? “
More than 390,000 in the first half of 2022 electric car sales! In comparison, 250,000 CNG vehicles were sold during the same period. If you look at the sales data alone, electric vehicles are undoubtedly more popular with Indians and have already occupied the Indian auto market!
But can we really infer from sales figures that EVs are better than CNG vehicles for city driving? Honest answer: no! A car is a very complex machine and here at CarJasoos we provide a detailed comparison of EV and CNG. Let’s get started now!
In addition, CNG and gasoline as well as electric and gasoline hybrids are also available on the market.But for this comparison we’ve only considered pure electric powertrains because the engine is required CNG vehicle Go to work.
CNG vs Electric Vehicles | Which Is The Most Economical Option For City Driving?
How does a CNG vehicle work?
CNG (compressed natural gas) is cheaper compared to petrol and diesel. In addition, it is more environmentally friendly and efficient. In addition, every CNG car is a CNG-gasoline hybrid. The engines of CNG vehicles start on gasoline, but can be switched to run on compressed natural gas. Plus, even if you don’t buy a CNG vehicle, you can get a CNG kit to install on your gasoline vehicle!
CNG vehicles use high-pressure CNG storage tanks stored in the trunk of the vehicle. This high-pressure gas is then supplied from the fuel tank to the fuel line. The regulator is used to reduce the pressure to the ideal pressure based on the engine’s fuel injection system. Air and compressed natural gas are then delivered to the combustion chamber. The mixture was finally ignited by the spark plug!
How does an electric car work?
Electric vehicles are highly efficient, cost-effective in the long run, and environmentally friendly. In addition, EVs have excellent performance and eliminate emissions of environmentally harmful gases.
Generally speaking, in general, electric car Use electricity by converting it into mechanical propulsion. Additionally, some studies claim that EVs can be up to 70 percent more efficient than conventional vehicles.
Electric vehicles replace the engine with a battery pack and electric motor. Lithium-ion cells or traditional lead-acid cells can be used to make battery packs. Lithium-ion batteries are used in Tesla vehicles. Batteries store electrical energy in the form of chemical energy. The motor then receives this energy. These motors then use a drivetrain to send power to the wheels.
also see
Top 5 *Best* Electric Cars in India (2022) 😍 – YouTube
What are the advantages and disadvantages of CNG?
Advantages of CNG-
- CNG is environmentally friendly because it is not a fossil fuel.
- CNG vehicles have lower emissions than conventional gasoline or diesel vehicles.
- The operating expenses of a CNG-fueled vehicle can be as low as Rs 2-3 per km!
- In terms of economy, it is the best alternative fuel after gasoline and diesel.
- Since CNG vehicles require an engine to run, a separate gasoline fuel tank is also provided. If the CNG runs out, you can switch to gasoline to power the car.
- Many manufacturers offer cars equipped with CNG kits on various well-known cars on the market.
- Almost all taxis, rickshaws and toll vehicles run on CNG only!
- CNG stations can be found in all 36 entities (28 states and 8 union territories) of India. Therefore, there are many CNG stations scattered all over the country.
- CNG cars have a longer range than gasoline and diesel cars!
Disadvantages of CNG-
- The CNG storage tank is installed in the trunk of the car. Eventually, this will use up storage space in the back!
- Also, the power output of a CNG car is about 10-20% lower than that of a gasoline or diesel car.
- However, refueling can be a pain! You often have to wait in long queues to get gas, especially in the morning!
Advantages of electric vehicles-
- Electric vehicles are the greenest alternative fuels in mass production today!
- Electric vehicles do not emit any gases that are harmful to the environment, that is, zero emissions!
- In addition, the government offers substantial tax breaks and ancillary incentives for the purchase of electric vehicles.
- Also, the operating cost of an EV could be as low as Rs 1-2 per km! Ultimately, electric vehicles have the lowest operating costs of all fuel alternative vehicles on the market!
- With no engine or complicated parts, EVs are also relatively cheap to maintain.
Disadvantages of electric vehicles-
- The cost of batteries has a big impact on the overall cost of an electric vehicle.
- Electric vehicles have a limited range.
- Locating charging facilities is especially challenging since electric vehicles are new to the market.
- Even if you find a charging station, it will take a while to charge your EV. A fast charger is the solution to this problem! However, not all sites have adopted it. Plus, it’s often already in use! As a result, charging an electric vehicle can take anywhere from 30 minutes to over 10 hours.
in conclusion
So, which type of vehicle is better for urban use?
If you choose CNG, a full tank will keep you stress-free for a day or two! If you have an electric car and charge it overnight at home, you can also go all day stress-free. But how many households have enough space for a charging station?
Even though EVs are more economical in terms of Rs. per kilometer spent, it also has its fair share of disadvantages!
Unless you live in a hilly area, you don’t need that much power or torque to get around the city. Therefore, both CNG and EV are ideal for basic urban transportation. For intra-city commuting, however, compressed natural gas may currently have the upper hand.
According to ongoing research and development, the range of electric vehicles is expanding. Electric vehicles (EV) may dominate the Indian market in a year or two! If you’d like to know if our opinion has changed, please come back and visit us again.
Feel free to share your opinion in the comments section below.
read also
Electricity, gasoline, CNG or diesel? Which fuel type should you buy in 2022?
There are a few things you should know before installing a CNG kit in your car
Top 7 Big Seven Seater Cars with Highest Mileage in India